How Do I Choose a Self-Directed IRA Custodian?

Key Points

An IRA must be held by a custodian, such as a bank, authorized trust company, or another entity approved by the IRS to act as an IRA custodian.
Opposed to most brokerages, Self-Directed IRA custodians allow you to invest in alternative assets like real estate, precious metals, and more.
To choose the best Self-Directed IRA custodian research their client reviews, security measures, and fees, among other factors.
Madison Trust offers a flat-fee schedule, unmatched client support, secure investing, and a streamlined investment process.
Choosing the best Self-Directed IRA custodian is essential for the success of your retirement investing. However, what qualifies as the best Self-Directed IRA custodian can differ based on a number of factors. Let's start off by discussing what a Self-Directed IRA custodian is, and then we'll explore the elements to consider when making a choice.

What is a Self-Directed IRA Custodian?

The Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 408 details that all IRAs must be held by a custodian, such as a bank, authorized trust company, or any other entity approved by the IRS to act as an IRA custodian. A Self-Directed IRA custodian is responsible for the following:
Blue circle with a white check mark inside
Holding the account’s investments in custody
Blue circle with a white check mark inside
Making transactions based on the direction of the IRA account holder
Blue circle with a white check mark inside
Complying with all IRS reporting requirements regarding the IRA, which includes filing IRS Forms 5498 and 1099-R
Blue circle with a white check mark inside
Maintaining the tax-advantaged status of the IRA

A Brief History of Self-Directed IRA Custodians

Most banks and financial institutions that offer IRAs limit account holder’s investment options to stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. However, as a result of the 2008 financial crisis many investors quickly became aware that alternative assets are the key to a diversified portfolio and can provide a hedge against the stock market. Therefore, to facilitate investing in alternative assets such as real estate, private equity, startups, promissory notes, and more, specialized Self-Directed IRA custodians, like Madison Trust, were established.

How To Choose The Best Self-Directed IRA Custodian

Now that you know the answer to "who is the custodian of a Self-Directed IRA," you need to decide which one is right for you. Here are some features to look for when deciding what Self-Directed IRA custodian is best for you.
Client Service Model and Reviews

There’s nothing more telling about a company’s commitment to amazing customer service than client reviews. Custodians should be as clear and transparent as possible with all matters involving your retirement funds. When you call Madison Trust you will be serviced by a knowledgeable, friendly representative. Our clients are our primary focus and we are committed to excellence.
Read More
When you call Madison Trust you will be serviced by a knowledgeable, friendly representative. Our clients are our primary focus and we are committed to excellence. This is evident through our A+ rating on the Better Business Bureau and the highest rating in the industry across all online rating platforms (such as Google, Yelp, Shopper Approved, etc.). We take our role in securing our client’s financial future seriously and strive to provide the easiest and most productive experience every time you contact us.
Excellent Security

When deciding on a custodian to hold your IRA, it is best to ensure that there are systems and controls in place to protect your personal and financial information. At Madison Trust, we take your security seriously. Your personal information is never sold to a third party. The employees who have access to this information are limited to those who need it to perform a specific job (for example, billing). Your sensitive information is protected online through encryption technology.
Read More
We also train our employees to be vigilant when handling personal information and to be on the lookout for any potentially fraudulent or suspicious activity. When you call Madison Trust, before we provide any account-specific information, we have a system in place to ensure we are speaking to the proper party. For more information, please visit our privacy policy.
Low Fees

Every custodian has a unique fee schedule and the only way to find out the fees for each is to make individual queries. Madison Trust employs an inexpensive, flat-rate fee schedule that never surprises you with unexpected or hidden fees.
Read More
Madison Trust’s fees remain the same no matter how much money accumulates in your account. You will never be charged more for being successful.
Wide Array of Asset Choice

When choosing an IRA custodian, be sure to understand which type of assets you are looking to invest in. Are you looking to go the more traditional route and invest in stocks, bonds, and mutual funds? Or, are you looking to diversify your portfolio even further by investing in alternative assets such as real estate, private equity, promissory notes, or more?
Read More
When you create a Self-Directed IRA at Madison Trust you have the power to invest in almost any alternative asset. Our team understands a wide array of asset classes and is here to answer all of your questions.
Ease of Account Set Up and Investing Process

The earlier you start saving and investing in your retirement, the better. Once your Madison Trust account is set up and funded, you can start investing immediately.
Read More
In addition, some custodians strictly hold custody of your Self-Directed IRA investments and do not offer any other services (such as the creation of an LLC). Madison Trust works closely with our sister company, Broad Financial, to provide the entity creation, support, and custody of your Self-Directed IRA together for a streamlined experience.
Size and Industry Expertise

The size of a custodian’s business tells you about their experience and expertise. If a company has a limited amount assets under custody, it may have fewer capabilities. Madison Trust has $4 billion+ in custodial assets, 15,000+ clients, and 1,500+ positive reviews, displaying our knowledge to accommodate all different types of assets.
Read More
Our team has CISP-trained Specialists, which is the highest training an IRA Specialist can receive, making us well-versed in the IRS rules and regulations for holding alternative assets in an IRA. We provide coverage of our IRA accounts and a dedicated support team for the entire U.S.
The best choice for a Self-Directed IRA custodian will also depend on what kind of assets an investor would like to purchase. Custodians differ greatly in the functionality they offer, and the right functionality is key for specific investments.

Here are some of the different services that Self-Directed IRA custodians offer their account holders.

Full-Service Custodian

What It Is: This is the classic setup for a Self-Directed IRA custodian. The custodian acts as the middle-man for every transaction and executes on demand. Does the account holder want to buy a property? They ask the custodian to facilitate the purchase. Does the account holder want to pay a bill? They ask the custodian to write a check. Basically, for anything that needs to be done, the custodian is asked to do it.

Pros: This kind of Self-Directed IRA custodian usually has the simplest and most economical setup. Also, there is a lot of interaction between the custodian and the account holder, which gives the account holder ample opportunity to ask questions.

Cons: This kind of account can grow very expensive, as its basic fee structure will either be asset-based or transaction-based. Neither of these are flat fees, and they can really take a bite out of your nest egg. Additionally, relying on the Self-Directed IRA custodian for time-sensitive transactions can be extremely frustrating. Paperwork and delays are standard for most companies, but in the investment realm, the consequences can be substantial.

This Account Is Best For: Investors who are considering low-transaction assets. If you are interested in the kind of investment that is not transaction-heavy, a full-service Self-Directed IRA custodian can be ideal. The setup is cheap, as you won't be managing the asset, and you can get started quickly. Just make sure to choose a custodian that doesn't charge asset-based fees based on the account’s value.

Checkbook Control Custodian

What It Is: Some Self-Directed IRA custodians offer account holders the option of checkbook control. This means that the account holder's IRA is attached to another financial vehicle (like a trust or an LLC), and that vehicle can open up a checking account. What this accomplishes is enabling the account holder to make transactions without going through the custodian. Any purchase or management activity can be accomplished directly by writing a check or sending a wire. In this case, the Self-Directed IRA LLC custodian would still be required to hold the IRA, but it wouldn't have to charge any additional fees.

Pros: The account holder can make as many transactions as they would like at no cost. Additionally, the transactions happen in real-time without any delay.

Cons: The setup fee for a Self-Directed IRA with checkbook control can be significantly higher than for a Self-Directed IRA. (This is due to the establishment of the LLC or trust.) That being said, the cost of setup is usually quickly offset by the savings in fees.

This Account Is Best For: Investors who are considering assets that require a lot of transactions. A common example would be a rental property that requires active management. No transaction or asset fees can help investors retain more of their savings. This kind of account is also good for investors whose investment model requires jumping on opportunities quickly.

The Power of Madison Trust

Incredible Client Support

Madison Trust was created with one goal: give retirement investors an amazing financial experience. The first step in that experience is unparalleled customer service. You’ll always be able to speak to a live and knowledgeable representative.
Read Our Reviews

Straightforward Fees

Madison’s Self-Directed IRA allows you to skip the asset-based fees and manage as you see fit. Amongst the lowest in the industry, our flat rates help ensure the profitability of your investments. Now you will never pay more for being successful.
Go to Calculator

Industry
Knowledge

Madison Trust Specialists have completed rigorous CISP training and have a deep understanding of a variety of alternative asset classes. That means every answer you will get is financially informed, no matter what asset you choose to invest in.
Explore Asset Options

How Much Are Self-Directed IRA Custodian Fees? 

One of the first things account holders want to know when setting up their account is "how much are IRA custodial fees"? Unfortunately, there's no universal answer, as Self-Directed IRA custodian fees can vary a great deal. Each Self-Directed IRA custodian can use a unique fee schedule, and the only way to find out the fees for each is to research. Then, you can put together a Self-Directed IRA fee comparison to decide which one works best for you.

The costs you'll want to evaluate in a Self-Directed IRA fee comparison are:

Setup: A one-time fee to cover the initial setup
Transaction: A series of fees that are applied for every requested transaction (i.e., purchasing an asset)
Asset-based: A fee charged annually or quarterly to maintain the IRA
Annual Maintenance: A fee charged annually or quarterly to maintain the IRA
Asset Markup: A fee charged by the Self-Directed IRA custodian when pricing a specific asset
Please see Madison Trust’s fee schedule for more information regarding our fees

What Kind of Self-Directed IRA is Best for Real Estate?

Choosing the right Self-Directed IRA real estate custodian depends on the nature of the real estate investment. We can break down real estate investments into two major categories for the purpose of choosing a Self-Directed Real Estate IRA custodian. The first is a real estate investment that is hands-off. This is where the investor contributes funds but a third party handles the management and business side of the investment. Examples of these include private REITs (real estate investment trusts) and private placements. Since involvement in these kinds of investments does not require any kind of transactions from the account holder, the classic Self-Directed custodian is the best fit. The account holder will be responsible for an inexpensive setup fee, light administrative fees, and the custodian's annual account fee. Due to the nature of the investment, though, they will be able to avoid expensive transaction fees.

The second category of real estate investment involves active management. This can include rehabs, fix-and-flips, and rental units. For these kinds of investments, a Self-Directed IRA custodian with checkbook control is a better fit. The reason for this is that these kinds of real estate assets require numerous transactions. Every contractor payment, deposited check, and maintenance action counts as another transaction. With a classic Self-Directed IRA custodian, the fees to handle these transactions can quickly become overwhelming. However, a Self-Directed IRA custodian that offers checkbook control does not charge any transaction fees. The setup may be a little bit more expensive, but it will quickly pay for itself.

Real Estate Investment in a Self-Directed IRA
Ready to find out more? Contact an IRA Specialist at Madison Trust today. 

Self-Directed IRA Custodian – FAQs

How do I get started and open a Self-Directed IRA?

Self-Directed IRAs have always been possible, they’re just not well known. The reason is because most big brokerages deal exclusively with stock market products. By opening an account with a specialized self-directed custodian, you get the freedom to invest in what makes sense to you.

It is a simple 3 step process to open a Self Directed IRA at Madison Trust. 

(1) Create an account by completing an online application 
(2) Fund your account 
(3) Instruct Madison Trust to invest in the asset of your choice by filling out an Investment Authorization Form.

Visit How To Set Up a Self Directed-IRA for more information.

Why haven’t I heard of a Self-Directed IRA custodian?

Self-Directed IRAs have always been possible, they’re just not well known. The reason is because most big brokerages deal exclusively with stock market products. By opening an account with a specialized self-directed custodian, you get the freedom to invest in what makes sense to you.

Ready to invest in your future?

Reach out to our team, and we’ll answer all of your questions.
All Pages Bottom Contact Form
Corporate Headquarters:
Madison Trust Company
401 East 8th Street • Suite 200
Sioux Falls, SD 57103
Mailing Address:
Madison Administration Company
One Paragon Drive • Suite 275
Montvale, NJ 07645
Hours:
Monday - Thursday: 9:00AM - 6:00PM EST
Friday: 10:00AM - 4:00PM EST
Saturday/Sunday: Closed
Contact:
(800) 721-4900
[email protected]
F: 845-947-1212
magnifiermenuchevron-down